An older deck does not automatically need replacement, and a fresh coat of finish does not automatically make it sound. The decision starts with supports, framing, connections, and the walking surface—not age alone.
Loose fasteners and a few worn boards may call for localized repairs. Soft framing, widespread deterioration, or movement at the house connection may point to a larger reconstruction. A surface-only estimate can miss those differences.
Bay Area fog and winter rain can keep hidden areas damp. Look for staining beneath the deck, damaged flashing, and places where water collects. Avoid using any area that feels unstable until it has been assessed.
Ask for a scope that separates what stays, what comes out, and what will be checked when the surface is opened. That makes repair and replacement options easier to compare.